1858


Hi Reader

On Substack this week I was going down a rabbit hole (too easy for me!) and I read something really interesting recently that we’ll call the “Diagram of the Causes of Mortality in the Army in the East”

In 1858 Florence Nightingale drew it as a circle of coloured wedges; one for every month of the Crimean War.

Red for deaths from wounds. Black for everything else. Blue for the diseases she called “preventible or mitigable.”

Interestingly, and as you can see, the blue swallowed the red.

Month after month the blue had the bigger ‘wedge’. But this level of detail wasn’t drawn up just to have an interesting set of information points; she drew it for ministers and officials who had the figures in front of them and still couldn’t see what they were saying. The numbers had been in front of them the whole time but now the wedges just made them impossible to gloss over.

You see, most of the soldiers died slowly in the wards; not of things everyone was counting but of things everyone ignored or couldn’t notice.

Volunteer leaders leave sports, professional and charity organisations the exact same way.


Thanks to this week's sponsor, 1440 - free, fact checked, unbiased news.

Unsubscribe any time!

Years back I was head coach of a team that had to be taken apart and built again around youth. We were playing at a level where you had to be good every week just to reach the table, and even then sitting at the table didn’t guarantee you a meal. We put a proper management group around the players; real high performers in their own right. One of them, who, like all the others, came in on a voluntary basis, looked after the performance analysis function. The detail he gave us was hard and clean and fair. More than that, he cared about the culture that would still be there when the results weren’t. For the first half of the season all was wonderful....an initial bounce gave us escape velocity and positive momentum. Then we hit a run of losses and sloppy performances. The blame started. Fingers pointed. The management group began managing instead of leading.

One night he simply wasn’t at the training session.

I heard the double-ding WhatsApp alert and just intuitively knew. His short text thanked me for having him on the management team, wished us luck and said he’d “seen this movie before”.

I felt ill at that moment because I knew the after-shock that would result from this seemingly small tremor. I’d seen the movie before too but consigned it to distant memory and not working memory.

As the weeks went by his absence was louder than any report he’d ever written. The glue he’d been quietly providing became obvious the moment it wasn’t there. The chats, the guidance wrapped in wit, the questions, just the look he’d give you that would lift you high or instantly let you know that something wasn’t quite what it should be.

A few cups of coffee later he came back, and the lift was immediate. We hadn’t been dying because of the results. We’d been dying because we were blind to the value a linchpin was delivering every day, and we only noticed when the music that we danced to stopped.


Similarly, Nightingale’s blue wedge was the part that could have been stopped. Most of what ushers volunteer leaders out the door is the same. It isn’t the row or disagreement or the tough moment or the toys-out-of-the-pram moment or the bad outcome or result that finishes them; those are the red wedges, the dramatic bits everyone sees. The blue is the accumulated load that was never counted. It’s the compounding quiet erosion that was always preventable, as hindsight proves, and almost always invisible until the person is just not there one night.

Even in 1858 the data existed. But the big step-change was that someone made the shape of the loss impossible to ignore. Today, the same choice sits in front of every organisation that keeps losing the people who hold the place together. The numbers of who left, and when, and after what, are, in almost all cases, already there. What’s absent is the ‘wedge’ that shows which colour is actually doing the damage.

This week in a quieter moment, if you drew your own chart, month by month or quarter by quarter, of the reasons the volunteer leaders actually walk away, which colour/wedge would be the biggest? And how much of it would you be guessing?


My line of work is helping volunteer-led or dependent organisations keep their volunteer leaders. It starts with confidential conversations that show where the pressure is landing, early enough to understand and act on it to relieve retention issues. If recruiting or retaining volunteer leaders is a live issue for you, just reply to this newsletter...drop an email to paul@theleaders.coach​


Another Newsletter you might find useful....

Daniel Hartweg - The Mindset Challenger

Daniel Hartweg - The Mindset Challenger

Join a thriving community of readers each week for insights on High Performance, Inspiring Leadership, Purpose-Driven Work and Personal Development. Subscribe to stay inspired and achieve your best!


Thank you for being part of this community.

The work on better personal performance is something you have to do alone.

But you don't have to do it on your own.

Onward and Upward,

Paul

​https://www.paulclarke.ie​

Connect with me at: https://www.linkedin.com/in/paulclarkeperform/​


Beechmount Vale, Navan, Meath C15
​Unsubscribe · Preferences​

Paul Clarke

Fine Lines is a weekly newsletter at the intersection of organisational prosperity and human development - for leaders who have already tried the obvious fixes and are now asking better questions. Each Tuesday: one idea from real experience and research, examined with enough rigour to be useful and enough honesty to sting slightly. The equation running underneath every edition: Capability × Ability = Performance. Most interventions address the Ability side. Fine Lines addresses the variable nobody is measuring. If you want frameworks and inspiration there are better newsletters. If you want your thinking challenged and, occasionally, your assumptions dismantled then you are in the right place.

Read more from Paul Clarke

Hi Reader For the first month of one pre-season, my management team was one person. Me. No assistants, no analyst, not even a kit-man. So every night through January and into February I did the jobs of three or four people, so the players would walk into a session that felt ordinary. Cones out. Balls pumped. Notes and analysis from the last session & a plan for the upcoming session written up and sent round before anyone asked. Everything ran….and that was the problem. Because nothing broke,...

Hi Reader It’s late on a weeknight, and somewhere a volunteer chairperson, or similar, is watching a former I’ve sat in a lot of interview rooms as a head-coach, and the sequence of events repeated in a regular, predictable way and rarely changed. The club’s leadership would talk about their standards and their lofty expectations for the season ahead. Fair enough, by the way. I worried more when they didn’t. Then I’d get the job, and the talking would stop. There were no notes on the players,...

Hi Reader It’s late on a weeknight, and somewhere a volunteer chairperson, or similar, is watching a former international footballer on YouTube explain that a “good dressing room” comes down to attitude, honesty and hunger. He’s not wrong. He’s just not much use on Thursday, when the committee meeting has three items nobody wants and the treasurer has gone quiet. Last week a sports club chairman, a volunteer in the role, told me what he’d most have liked when he started: someone to explain...